This week we’re talking about virtue ethics, the ethical framework that guides moral actions based on evaluations of moral character. Right moral action is based in virtue, and wrong moral action is based in vice.

In contrast to modern theories, it asks not what we should do, but what should we be. Of course, a virtuous character is based in good acts. One can’t be virtuous merely by believing the right thing. But by calling this the “morality of being,” we are highlighting that how you act is constitutive of the kind of person you are. If you say you believe in charity for the poor, but never give of your own time or money, then we would not say that you are a charitable person.

Aristotle
Aristotle

By contrast, modern theories focus on (crisis) decision-making. A utilitarian sizes up a problematic moral situation, calculates the total harms and benefits that would be produced by different courses of action, and picks the one that produces the greatest overall good. Then the utilitarian’s moral faculty can go on holiday until the next crisis of decision arises. Not so for the virtue ethicist. She recognizes that ethics has to do with how we live our lives–every single day. She sees virtue as a potential that has to be actualized over the course of a whole life. This is a theory of moral development.

The scope of morality includes these questions:
How do you choose your friends?
What do you do on the weekends?
What books do you read?
How have you chosen to live your life?
Is it an admirable life?

Some modern ethical and political theories influenced by virtue ethics are “the capabilities approach” to ethics, care ethics, and communitarianism.

Virtue ethics also dissolves the conflict between individual and society that we saw in utilitarianism because individuals and their communities can be seen as interdependent. Virtuous individuals value friendships and build strong communities; at the same time, resilient, trusting, creative communities help us to reach our potential as individuals. Virtue theorists believe that the point of ethics is to guide us in living well, with virtue, and in building communities at all levels (families, friends, communities, nations) which support the people that make them up.

Advertisement